top of page
Search

The Complicated Business of Helping People

Nov 10
4 min read

I was recently visiting friends when one of them mentioned, somewhat sheepishly, that she had joined what was essentially a life coaching group. It had done a lot for her, she explained, but there was a little hesitation in how she described it. I understood that hesitation. I often feel something similar when I think about describing myself as a life coach. In many ways, it is an accurate description of what I do. Still, I tend to avoid the term because of everything it can carry with it.


There is legitimate, useful work happening under the umbrella of life coaching. There are also people making promises they cannot support, working beyond their abilities, and using someone’s desire for a better life to gain money, influence, or control. That makes the landscape confusing for the person looking for help, and, at least for me, uncomfortable as someone offering it. I understand why people are skeptical. I also think something valuable gets lost when embarrassment keeps us from talking openly about help that has actually helped.


Lately, I have been listening to a podcast about NXIVM, an organization that offered personal development programs and whose leader, Keith Raniere, was convicted of crimes including racketeering and sex trafficking. I have felt similar discomfort hearing about Jodi Hildebrandt, a licensed therapist who ran a self-improvement program and pleaded guilty to four counts of aggravated child abuse. These are distinct cases with their own facts and devastating consequences. But both bring me back to questions about the authority we give people who promise to help us improve our lives.


One of the most uncomfortable parts of listening is recognizing some of the ideas. As former participants describe what they were taught, I sometimes hear principles that, considered on their own, I think are sound: examine your assumptions, recognize patterns, take responsibility for your behavior, and consider that your interpretation may not be the only one available. These are things I talk about with people regularly. Hearing familiar ideas in these accounts makes me pause. Am I missing something about what I teach? Could I be encouraging something problematic? Am I helping people expand their perspectives, or asking them to adopt mine?


I do not think that resemblance alone answers those questions. A useful principle can be stretched beyond its usefulness, stripped of context, or applied in a way that causes harm. Taking responsibility for your behavior can help you recognize where you have choices. Taken to an extreme, it can become an insistence that everything that happens to you is your fault, including someone else’s abuse. Questioning your assumptions can create room for understanding. If every objection you raise is treated as proof that your thinking is defective, however, you have lost the ability to question the person asking you to question yourself.


That is where I keep returning to the relationship surrounding the ideas. What happens when someone disagrees? Can they say that an interpretation does not fit, that an exercise feels intrusive, or that they want to stop? Does the practitioner get curious, reconsider, and make room for that response? Or does disagreement become evidence that the person is resistant, unwilling to grow, or incapable of seeing the truth? A framework becomes especially troubling to me when every possible response is used to confirm it. Agreement proves it works, and disagreement proves how badly you need it.


Of course, useful work can be uncomfortable. I am often direct with people, and I sometimes offer observations they would rather not consider. If we only examine ideas that already feel familiar and reassuring, we may have very little opportunity to change. But discomfort deserves attention and discussion. It should not become automatic evidence that the practitioner is right. Someone’s willingness to seek help does not give me unrestricted permission to define their experience for them.


What I hope to offer is another perspective that a person can consider alongside their own experience, values, and judgment. They may find it useful. They may need to adjust it. They may reject it, and sometimes that rejection may help me recognize where I have misunderstood them. Being open to those possibilities does not prevent me from having a point of view or challenging someone. It does require me to remember that my interpretation is an interpretation, even when I feel strongly about it.


I also have to be careful about what I make of my own concern. The fact that I worry about these questions does not establish that I am practicing responsibly. Good intentions and thoughtful reflection need to show up in how I work: being clear about the service I am providing, recognizing the limits of my competence, seeking consultation, and responding seriously when someone tells me I have gotten something wrong. Hildebrandt’s professional background is a particularly uncomfortable reminder that credentials alone cannot settle the question of whether someone is using their authority responsibly.


For someone seeking help, I think it is reasonable to look beyond whether the practitioner is compelling or whether a particular idea sounds insightful. Pay attention to what happens when you ask questions, set a limit, or express uncertainty. Are costs and commitments clear? Can you seek another opinion and maintain relationships outside the group? Can you decide that something is not for you without that decision being treated as a personal failure? These questions matter even when parts of the experience have been beneficial. Something can help you in one respect and still ask too much of you in another.


I may continue to feel some discomfort with the term life coach, but I am clear about the purpose of the work. Good help should expand a person’s ability to understand themselves, consider other perspectives, and make choices informed by their own values. The person offering that help has a responsibility to make room for disagreement, acknowledge the limits of their understanding, and remain accountable for how they use their influence. There will always be judgment involved in knowing when to challenge and when to reconsider, and I expect to keep questioning myself along the way. But I want the direction to be clear: the people I work with should become more capable of directing their own lives, including deciding when my help is no longer useful.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page