top of page
Search

Old Beliefs, Evolving Values: Rethinking What Guides Us

Nov 4
8 min read

There's a familiar saying that what got you here won't get you there. I've always thought there was something valuable in that idea, but I also think it deserves a little more consideration. Because what got you here may have been exactly what you needed. The beliefs you developed, the assumptions you made, and the ways you learned to navigate the world likely served an important purpose. They helped you manage circumstances, build relationships, protect yourself, accomplish goals, and perhaps become quite successful. There's no reason to dismiss those approaches simply because they were developed earlier in life. But there's also no reason to assume they're the best approaches for the person you are today.


Several years ago, I began doing some personal work examining what are sometimes called old beliefs or core beliefs in psychological work. These are conclusions we've developed through our experiences about ourselves, other people, and how the world works. Some form quite early, when we have limited information and relatively little experience to draw upon. Others develop later, through relationships, professional experiences, and the circumstances we encounter. What struck me was how much influence some of these old beliefs continued to have over how I showed up in the world, even when they no longer reflected what I consciously believed or who I wanted to be. That realization has shaped much of the work I've done with clients in the years since. I've watched people experience similar moments of recognition, when they begin to see that a familiar response isn't necessarily a reflection of their current values or considered judgment. It's an old belief operating so automatically that they haven't thought to question it.


Consider the difference between valuing responsibility and holding the old belief, "I have to be responsible." Responsibility may be a deeply held value. It can reflect integrity, accountability, and a commitment to following through on what matters. But the old belief that I have to be responsible may carry an entirely different set of expectations. Perhaps it means I must anticipate everyone else's needs, prevent things from going wrong, or take ownership of problems that aren't actually mine to solve. The distinction isn't necessarily in the words themselves, but in how we relate to them.


When I identify responsibility as a value, I have an opportunity to consider what responsibility means to me today. Perhaps it means following through on my commitments, being accountable for my decisions, and recognizing when something is mine to manage. Six months from now, that understanding might evolve. I may come to recognize that being responsible also means allowing others to take ownership of their decisions, establishing healthier boundaries, or acknowledging the limits of what I can reasonably accomplish. I haven't abandoned responsibility as a value. I've expanded my understanding of what it means to practice it. An old belief, on the other hand, often doesn't receive that same consideration. If I learned years ago that I have to be responsible, I may continue operating according to whatever responsibility meant to me at the time, automatically taking charge or assuming obligations without considering whether those responses make sense in my current circumstances.


This is what I find particularly interesting about the relationship between values and old beliefs. Our values can provide a consistent foundation without requiring us to maintain a fixed definition of what they mean. We can revisit them as we accumulate experience, gain perspective, and move through different stages of life. Even the values we prioritize may change. Old beliefs, meanwhile, can remain remarkably unchanged, not because we've carefully considered them and decided they still fit, but because we haven't necessarily recognized that they're influencing us in the first place. One approach invites curiosity, reflection, and choice. The other can become a relatively rigid rule that continues operating without much conscious examination. And importantly, examining an old belief doesn't necessarily mean rejecting it.


One of the things I encourage people to do is become more curious about their own interpretations. When someone disappoints us, when a colleague disagrees with us, or when a situation doesn't unfold the way we expected, we tend to develop an explanation for what's happening. Often, we do this so quickly that we don't even recognize we've made an assumption. We may decide that someone doesn't respect us, that we're being taken advantage of, or that our perspective isn't being considered. Sometimes those interpretations are accurate, but sometimes they're incomplete. What else could be going on? What information might I be missing? What assumptions am I making about this person's intentions? And perhaps just as importantly, what's happening within me that's contributing to the way I'm interpreting and responding to this situation?


We might also ask which values we want guiding our response. If I value respect, what does respect look like in this particular situation? Does it mean listening more carefully, expressing disagreement directly, or establishing a boundary? The purpose of asking these questions isn't to convince ourselves that our initial interpretation was wrong. We may consider several alternative explanations and still arrive at exactly the same conclusion. But now we've arrived there through a more intentional process. We've considered additional information and perspectives rather than relying exclusively on our first reaction, and we can feel more confident in the thinking that informed our decision.


That's an important distinction, particularly when it comes to confidence. We often associate confident decision-making with being certain that we've made the right choice, but we can't guarantee outcomes, regardless of how carefully we think through a decision. What we can do is develop confidence in the process we use. We can consider relevant information, examine competing perspectives, identify our values, acknowledge potential risks, and make the best decision available to us. If the outcome isn't what we hoped for, we don't necessarily have to conclude that our judgment was poor. We can recognize that we made a thoughtful decision with the information we had, incorporate what we've learned, and decide what to do next. The process remains valuable even when the outcome is disappointing.


I think this becomes especially important in our relationships, both personal and professional. Most of us would probably say that we value things like respect, integrity, fairness, or connection. But those values can become surprisingly difficult to practice when we feel threatened, dismissed, or misunderstood. Conflict, in particular, has a way of shifting our focus from understanding and problem-solving to winning and losing. We become so invested in defending our position that we may lose sight of how we want to treat the person on the other side of the disagreement. And winning an argument at the expense of a relationship isn't always much of a victory.


I may genuinely value connection, but if I'm operating from an old belief that disagreement means disrespect, I may respond defensively to someone whose relationship I care deeply about. I may value fairness, but if I automatically assume others are trying to take advantage of me, I may approach a conversation with suspicion before I've even understood the other person's perspective. My values haven't necessarily changed, but my behavior may be guided by an old belief I haven't stopped to examine. This matters because our relationships influence nearly every aspect of our lives. They shape our personal well-being, our professional opportunities, our sense of belonging, and our ability to accomplish things that require the cooperation of others. Being talented, intelligent, or successful doesn't eliminate the need to work well with people, yet we can become so convinced of the correctness of our own perspective that we stop being curious about anyone else's.


This is one reason I believe personal and professional development are far more connected than we sometimes acknowledge. The person navigating a difficult conversation with a spouse is the same person navigating a disagreement with a colleague. The old beliefs that influence how we respond to criticism at home don't necessarily disappear when we walk into a meeting. Neither do our values. Of course, we adapt our behavior to different environments. We may be more casual with family than with colleagues, and different roles come with different responsibilities and expectations. But that doesn't mean we need entirely different standards for who we are or how we want to engage with other people. There's something powerful about developing a more integrated sense of self, one in which our values provide a consistent foundation while our understanding of how to practice them remains flexible enough to accommodate different circumstances.


This is also where the question of growth becomes particularly interesting. When people seek out therapy, coaching, or other forms of personal and professional development, they're typically looking for something to change. Perhaps they want stronger relationships, greater confidence, more effective leadership, or a different experience of their everyday lives. But we can become surprisingly attached to the very patterns that have helped create our current circumstances. If we continue thinking, interpreting, and responding in the same ways, we shouldn't be particularly surprised when we continue producing similar results. That doesn't mean those patterns were bad. They may have been remarkably effective and helped us build exactly the life or career we have today. But if we're hoping to arrive somewhere different, it makes sense that we may need to approach the journey differently.


And while that sounds simple, it's often anything but. I often remind clients that some of the changes we're working toward are fairly simple concepts, but frustratingly difficult to execute. Recognizing an old belief and understanding how we'd like to respond differently doesn't mean we'll suddenly stop operating from it. These patterns may have been reinforced over many years, and changing them takes patience, attention, and practice. Even when we understand what we'd like to do differently, changing the old beliefs and assumptions underlying our behavior can require a different kind of attention. It asks us to become curious about things we've spent years accepting as true and to consider that our familiar ways of operating may not be the only ways available to us. The encouraging part is that we don't have to abandon what we've learned along the way. We get to build upon it, combining the experiences that shaped us with the wisdom we've accumulated since.


Our values can be particularly useful in this process because they provide an opportunity to consider who we are today and how we want to show up in the world. And just as our old beliefs deserve examination, so do our values. The values that feel most important to us today may not be the same ones we prioritize six months or five years from now. Even when a particular value remains important, our understanding of what it means can change. Responsibility, independence, success, or connection may look quite different at different points in our lives. That's part of the beauty of approaching values intentionally. We can continue examining what they mean to us, how we want to practice them, and whether they're guiding us toward the lives and relationships we want.


So perhaps the question isn't whether the old beliefs that got us here were right or wrong. It's whether they're still relevant to the lives we're living and the people we want to be. If they are, we can choose to continue operating from them while remaining open to reconsidering them as we evolve. But when we recognize that an old belief is no longer serving us, our values can help us identify what we'd like to put in its place. Rather than simply trying to stop an automatic response, we can ask ourselves what matters to us today, what that value means in our current circumstances, and what a response grounded in that understanding might look like. We can begin noticing when the old belief shows up and intentionally practice responding from the perspective we've chosen instead. Perhaps that's what it means to continue growing: not rejecting the old beliefs that helped us get here, but remaining curious about whether they still belong in the life we're creating, and allowing our consciously examined, evolving values, rather than our unexamined old beliefs, to guide where we go next.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page