The Case for Thoughtful Conviction
It's election season, and as national attention turns toward consequential races across the country, I've found myself thinking about our political divisions and the ways our beliefs shape how we relate to one another. I've also been thinking about Iowa, the state I've always considered home and one that's receiving plenty of national attention itself.

I was born in Iowa, although my parents' education and careers took our family elsewhere. My dad's family has lived there for generations, and much of my childhood was spent visiting my grandparents in Parkersburg, a small farming town of roughly 1,800 people. That's about the same number of students who attend my son's high school. As a child, visiting Parkersburg felt like stepping into a Norman Rockwell painting. It was safe, peaceful, familiar, and full of people who knew one another and looked out for one another. Community wasn't something you had to seek out. It was simply part of life.
But it wasn't always peaceful. I remember sitting in my grandparents' house, waiting for supper while my dad and grandpa engaged in sometimes heated political conversations. They often disagreed, but I don't remember those conversations being demeaning. I remember two people who took their own perspectives seriously while continuing to respect the person sitting across from them. They'd debate until my grandma announced it was time to eat. Then we'd sit down to ham, corn, potatoes, and probably a Jell-O salad. After dinner, my aunt would play the piano, and we'd sing hymns.
It's almost comically idyllic, I know. And I don't mean to suggest my family, or Parkersburg, was without complications. But those memories have stayed with me because they represent something I've come to appreciate more deeply as I've gotten older: the ability to hold strong convictions without allowing them to define the entirety of our relationships. My dad and grandpa didn't need to resolve their disagreements to maintain their connection. Nor did their affection require them to abandon their beliefs. Disagreement was part of their relationship, not necessarily a threat to it. I wonder how often we remember that distinction today.
As a young adult, I spent a year living with my grandma (my grandpa had died several years earlier) in Parkersburg. Although my family name was familiar in town, I was an outsider. I wasn't sure how I'd be received or how much people might assume they already knew about me. Fortunately, we gave each other a chance. I discovered people, perspectives, and experiences I might never have encountered otherwise, and I think the people of Parkersburg got to know me as an individual rather than simply an extension of my family. It was a reminder of how much we can miss when we assume we already know someone.
The following year, I began law school at the University of Iowa, and my appreciation for the state developed into something closer to fascination. I'd always loved Iowa for its sense of community, but I began to recognize something else: a relatively small, largely rural state with an influence on national conversations that often defied expectations.
In January 2008, during my first year of law school, Iowa's Democratic caucus voters helped propel Barack Obama's presidential candidacy. The following year, the Iowa Supreme Court unanimously recognized same-sex couples' constitutional right to marry. Both were significant moments in national politics, unfolding in a state many Americans might not have expected to be at the forefront of those conversations. Admittedly, both outcomes aligned with my political leanings. But what fascinated me wasn't simply that Iowa had reached conclusions I agreed with. It was the complexity of a predominantly white, rural state, home to many socially conservative communities, playing such an influential role in challenging national expectations.
Neither outcome represented universal agreement among Iowans. Obama's victory came from Democratic caucus participants, and the marriage ruling generated significant opposition. But that was part of what made Iowa interesting to me. There wasn't one Iowa, one set of beliefs, or one predictable way its people would respond to the questions facing the country. And perhaps the most interesting illustration of that complexity comes from two classmates I met during my first week of law school.
One, a Republican and one of my closest friends to this day, has served as chief of staff to Iowa's first female governor. The other, a Democrat, is running for governor right now and getting a lot of national attention. Both are intelligent, passionate, hardworking people with deeply held convictions. Both have dedicated significant portions of their careers to influencing the direction of the same state, often from fundamentally different perspectives.
I find that fascinating. Here are two people who are the same age, attended the same law school, care deeply about the same state, and have pursued very different visions of its future. Their differences aren't evidence that one cares about Iowa and the other doesn't. They're evidence that people can care deeply about the same thing and disagree profoundly about what's best for it.
Of course, that doesn't mean every conclusion is equally sound or that the consequences of different political positions are interchangeable. But knowing these two people personally helps me resist the temptation to reduce them to their political identities. I know there's more to each of them than the positions they hold. And I think that's something we have a responsibility to remember, even when we don't have the benefit of knowing someone personally. What might change if we approached political differences with more curiosity about how people arrived at their convictions, rather than assuming those convictions tell us everything we need to know about them?
I think our current political climate makes that increasingly difficult. Our political beliefs have become deeply intertwined with our identities. They don't simply reflect what we think about public policy; they can become expressions of who we believe ourselves to be, what we value, and where we belong. When a belief becomes closely tied to our identity, having it challenged can feel less like an exchange of ideas and more like a personal threat. We become defensive, seek information that reinforces what we already believe, and may begin to view disagreement as evidence that someone is fundamentally different from us.
These are understandable human responses, but they can make it harder to do something we're fundamentally wired to do: live in relationship with one another. For all our emphasis on individuality and independence, human beings are communal creatures. We develop our identities through relationships and depend on one another for connection, belonging, safety, and support. Even the most independent among us relies on communities and institutions that make that independence possible. And because we're connected, our choices rarely affect only ourselves.
We rightly place enormous value on the freedom to think for ourselves, develop our beliefs, and express our opinions. Those freedoms are essential. But we sometimes seem to confuse having the right to hold a belief with having no responsibility to consider its consequences. Our beliefs influence how we treat people, the policies we support, the leaders we elect, and the opportunities we make available to others. And the people affected by those decisions aren't abstractions. They're our neighbors, coworkers, friends, family members, and people whose lives may look very different from our own.
We don't have to agree with them, abandon our values, or pretend every perspective is equally informed or beneficial. But shouldn't we at least be willing to consider them? I think that's what thoughtful conviction requires.
It means taking our beliefs seriously enough to examine them. Asking not only what we believe, but why, what information supports those beliefs, and what consequences may follow when we act on them. It means recognizing that the strength of a conviction isn't measured solely by how firmly we defend it. Sometimes it's demonstrated by our willingness to challenge our assumptions, acknowledge complexity, or change our minds when presented with better information. And sometimes it means holding firmly to a belief while remaining respectful toward someone who disagrees.
This isn't a suggestion that we should all meet in the middle. Compromise isn't always possible or appropriate. Some disagreements involve fundamental questions of rights, safety, dignity, and opportunity, and the consequences of political decisions aren't always distributed equally. Prioritizing relationships doesn't mean overlooking harm or treating every position as morally equivalent. But it does mean recognizing that how we engage with one another matters, even when our disagreements can't be resolved.
We can challenge ideas without automatically dismissing the people who hold them. We can acknowledge the humanity of someone whose choices we strongly oppose. And we can remain curious about another person's perspective without surrendering our own.
Perhaps rural communities offer a useful reminder of why this matters. In a small town, the person who disagrees with you politically may also be the person who helps when your basement floods, coaches your child's baseball team, or checks on your elderly parent. You don't always have the luxury of reducing someone to a political position because your lives are connected in ways that extend beyond politics. Of course, small communities aren't inherently more welcoming or tolerant than large ones. My memories of Iowa reflect the belonging I was fortunate to experience, and I recognize that others have experienced a very different Iowa. But there's something valuable in remembering that our relationships and responsibilities don't disappear simply because we disagree.
As Election Day approaches, I find myself thinking again about those conversations between my dad and grandpa. I don't remember who made the better argument or whether either persuaded the other to change his mind. What I remember is that they could disagree, sometimes passionately, and still sit down together afterward.
Not every political disagreement can or should end that way. Some differences carry consequences that make relationships genuinely difficult to sustain. But our convictions and our connections aren't necessarily competing interests. We are entitled to think for ourselves, develop beliefs, defend our values, and make choices that reflect what matters to us. But we're also responsible for considering how those choices affect the people with whom we share our communities and our country.
That responsibility doesn't require less conviction. It asks something more of our convictions: curiosity, reflection, humility, and a willingness to consider perspectives beyond our own. As we prepare to make decisions that will shape our communities and our country, I hope we remember that thoughtful conviction and meaningful connection aren't mutually exclusive. In fact, I think each makes the other more valuable.



Comments